Cities of Lost Memory · Rome

Superstition

Rome · 2023
Indian ink on paper · 50 × 65 cmClick the image to inspect the original

A black cat stares out from the darkness. Behind it, what first reads like a full moon slowly becomes a face: the ancient marble disk known as the Bocca della Verità. Two superstitions, separated by centuries, occupy the same image.

WorkSuperstition
Date2023
MediumIndian ink on paper
Dimensions50 × 65 cm
PlaceRome
PrintLithograph, 2023 · edition of 50
Visual reading

Three gazes

The drawing is deliberately spare. The cat’s pale eyes meet the viewer first. Behind them, the pierced eyes of Oceanus are dark and empty. The marble itself is a third presence: a fragment of antiquity that has accumulated meanings long after its original function disappeared.

Detail of the black cat in Superstition
The catA familiar omen turned into the image’s most direct gaze.
Detail of the Bocca della Verità face in Superstition
OceanusThe ancient face emerges only after the eye adjusts to the black field.
The Bocca della Verità in Santa Maria in Cosmedin, Rome
The stoneThe Bocca della Verità in Santa Maria in Cosmedin, Rome.
History & memory

A drain that learned to judge

The Bocca della Verità is a large ancient Roman marble disk, probably dating to the second century CE. Its bearded face is generally identified with Oceanus. The openings through the eyes, nostrils and mouth make a practical origin plausible: rather than a cult image, it was most likely part of Rome’s water or drainage infrastructure.

Once its original function had been forgotten, the object acquired another life. Medieval Rome was full of ancient statues whose meanings were no longer understood. Pagan images could be treated as uncanny presences, and stories grew around them. The disk became the “Mouth of Truth”, credited with the power to expose lies and, eventually, to punish the dishonest by biting off a hand placed inside its mouth.

The historical object did not change. What changed was the story people needed it to tell.

The legend survived Christianity, antiquarian scholarship and modern tourism. In the twentieth century it reached an enormous international audience through Roman Holiday (1953), when Gregory Peck frightens Audrey Hepburn with the famous hand-in-the-mouth trick. A Roman drain cover had become an oracle, then a test of fidelity, then a tourist ritual — without ever ceasing to be the same piece of marble.

Antiquity

A Roman marble disk, probably associated with water and drainage, bearing the face of Oceanus.

Middle Ages

Its practical meaning faded and the stone accumulated legends about truth, deceit and supernatural punishment.

Modern Rome

The ritual persists as popular culture: visitors still queue to place a hand inside the mouth.

Bocca della Verità, Rome
Bocca della Verità · Basilica of Santa Maria in Cosmedin, Rome.
The drawing's trick

Moon, mask, manhole

The circular composition encourages an immediate mistake. At a glance, the stone resembles a moon behind the cat. Only gradually do the eyes, nose, mouth and beard resolve into the face of Oceanus.

That misreading is part of the work. A utilitarian object becomes divine, demonic and magical because people project stories onto it. The cat performs the same operation. It is simply an animal, yet centuries of folklore can make its colour and its path into a sign.

The image is not about believing one superstition. It is about the human appetite for turning objects, animals and accidents into messages.
Making the drawing

From circle to face

Five stages from the work-in-progress sequence show the structure clearly: the black cat and circular boundary establish the composition first; the face of Oceanus is then built inside the disk; the broad surrounding black field arrives last and changes the image from study to apparition.

Early stage of Superstition

1 · Cat, eyes and circular boundary establish the entire geometry.

Early face emerging in Superstition

2 · The first dark marks begin to locate the ancient face.

Intermediate stage of Superstition

3 · Oceanus becomes legible while much of the disk remains untouched paper.

Late stage of Superstition

4 · The outer black field closes around the disk and cat.

Near-final stage of Superstition

5 · Texture and tonal density bring the marble face into its final balance.

Superstition framed in exhibition
Exhibition view · Superstition framed on the wall.
Exhibition

The black field leaves the page

Seen framed and at distance, the composition becomes even more deceptive. The broad black brushwork first reads as a single nocturnal mass; only then do the cat and the ancient face separate from it.

The work has been shown as part of the Cities of Lost Memory exhibition cycle.

The surviving exhibition photograph does not securely identify its venue.

Sources & further reading

The afterlife of the Mouth of Truth

  • Lost Memory Art — the artist’s account of the Bocca della Verità, its changing meanings and the conception of the drawing. Read online.
  • Mirabilia Urbis Romae — the medieval guide tradition through which ancient Roman monuments were repeatedly reinterpreted for later visitors.
  • Roman Holiday (William Wyler, 1953) — the film that turned the Mouth of Truth legend into one of Rome’s most internationally recognisable tourist rituals.

Lithograph specifications follow the current Lost Memory Art webshop listing: 2023, 50 × 35 cm, edition of 50, Rives BFK 270 g, printed by Bruno Robbe.